Commodore Submarine Service

Post in the Royal Navy

Commodore Submarine Service
Ensign of the Royal Navy
Incumbent Commodore Paul Dunn OBE since 26 July 2022
Ministry of Defence
Member of	Board of Admiralty, Admiralty Board
Reports to	Fleet Commander
Nominator	Secretary of State for Defence
Appointer	Prime Minister Subject to formal approval by the Queen-in-Council
Term length	Not fixed (typically 2–3 years)
Inaugural holder	Rear-Admiral Douglas Dent
Formation	1901

Commodore Submarine Service is a post in the Royal Navy which involves command of the Royal Navy Submarine Service. It evolved from the post of Inspecting Captain of Submarines in 1901 and would later evolve to become the post of Flag Officer Submarines in 1944.

History

In 1904 the Admiralty created the post of Inspecting Captain of Submarines which lasted until August 1912 when Captain Roger J. B. Keyes was appointed Commodore, Submarine Service. He held that position until February 1919^[1] when the post holder was renamed Chief of the Submarine Service. It was for many years located at HMS Dolphin in Hampshire.^[2]

On 30 August 1939 Rear Admiral Submarines, Rear Admiral Bertram Watson, moved his headquarters from Gosport to Aberdour, Scotland, though the administrative staff remained at Gosport. The RN started the Second World War with 60 submarines.^[3] On 31 August 1939 the Second Submarine Flotilla at Dundee (Forth and ten submarines) and the Sixth Submarine Flotilla at Blyth (Titania and six submarines) were part of the Home Fleet. The submarines Clyde and Severn, part of the Seventh Submarine Flotilla, were at Freetown under the orders of the Commander-in-Chief, South Atlantic. Ten submarines were in the Mediterranean along with the depot ship Maidstone (First Submarine Flotilla); and the submarine depot ship Medway and the Fourth Submarine Flotilla were under the Commander-in-Chief, China, split between Singapore and Hong Kong.^[4] Roskill writes that the effective naval strength of the British Empire on the outbreak of war included 38 submarines.^[4]

During the war the major operating arenas were the Norwegian waters; the Mediterranean where the Tenth Submarine Flotilla fought a successful battle against the Axis replenishment route to North Africa; and the Far East where Royal Navy submarines disrupted Japanese shipping operating in the Malacca Straits.^[5]

In January 1940, Vice-Admiral Max Horton was made Rear Admiral Submarines. Horton's biographer, Rear Admiral William S. Chalmers, cites the opinion that a new regulation, which required the post holder to be an officer who had served aboard submarines in the Great War, was forced through for the sole purpose of ensuring that Horton was on a very short list of qualifiers for this post, almost ensuring his rapid transfer to Aberdour, so great was the desire of some within the Admiralty to have Horton revitalize the submarine arm.^[6]

From 1953 the Flag Officer Submarines was dual-hatted as NATO Commander Submarine Force Eastern Atlantic (COMSUBEASTLANT) under Commander Submarine Allied Command Atlantic (COMSUBACLANT), a major command of Supreme Allied Commander Atlantic. Flag Officer Submarines moved from Dolphin to the Northwood Headquarters in 1978.^[7] From 1993 the post of Flag Officer Submarines was dual-hatted with the post of Commander Operations.^[8]

In 2015, Rear Admiral John Weale was appointed Rear Admiral Submarines/Assistant Chief of Naval Staff Submarines, while Rear Admiral Robert Tarrant is Commander Operations (Royal Navy), two distinct posts from 2015.^[9]^[8] In 2016, a new entity, the Submarine Flotilla, was technically established, but its commander's post was to be held by Commander Faslane Flotilla.^[10] A single submarine base was to be achieved by 2020 when HMS Talent and HMS Triumph moved their homeports to the Clyde in 2019 and 2020 respectively.^[10]

On 1 April 2020, the post of Commander Submarine Flotilla was announced at HMNB Clyde,^[11] seemingly a renaming of the post of Commander Faslane Flotilla.^[11]

As of December 2020, official Royal Navy Freedom of Information responses said that "the combined 2* Rear Admiral post of Assistant Chief of the Naval Staff (ACNS) (Submarines)(SM), Flag Officer Scotland and Northern Ireland (FOSNI) and Rear Admiral Submarines has been disestablished. The ACNS (SM) role and Rear Admiral Submarines roles have been [lowered] to Commodore and retitled Deputy Director Submarines and Commodore Submarine Service. The role of Flag Officer Scotland and Northern Ireland role has been retitled as Senior Naval Officer Scotland and Northern Ireland (SNOSNI) and is currently held by 1* Deputy Director Submarines."^[12]

Commanding

Post holders have included:^[8]

Inspecting Captain of Submarines

Captain Reginald H. S. Bacon, 20 August 1901 – 21 October 1904^[1] Initial appointment title was Inspecting Captain of Submarine Boats (Richard Compton-Hall, 115).
Captain Edgar Lees, 21 October 1904, (later RAdm.)^[1]
Captain Sydney S. Hall, 12 November 1906 – 14 November 1910 (later Adm.)^[1]
Captain Roger J. B. Keyes, 14 November 1910 - July 1912^[1]

Commodore Submarine Service

Commodore Roger J. B. Keyes, August 1912 – February 1915^[1]

Chief of the Submarine Service

Rear-Admiral Douglas Dent (1919–1921)
Rear-Admiral Hugh Sinclair (1921–1923)
Vice-Admiral Wilmot Nicholson (1923–1925)
Rear-Admiral Vernon Haggard (1925–1927)
Rear-Admiral Henry Grace (1927–1929)

Rear-Admiral Submarines

Rear-Admiral Martin Dunbar-Nasmith (1929–1931)
Rear-Admiral Charles Little (1931–1932)
Rear-Admiral Noel Laurence (1932–1934)
Rear-Admiral Cecil Talbot (1934–1936)
Rear-Admiral Robert Raikes (1936–1938)
Rear-Admiral Bertram Watson (1938–1940)
Vice-Admiral Sir Max Horton (1940–1942)
Rear-Admiral Claud Barry (1942–1944)

Flag Officer Submarines

Rear-Admiral George Creasy (1944–1946)
Vice-Admiral Sir John Mansfield (1946–1948)
Rear-Admiral Guy Grantham (1948–1950)
Rear-Admiral Sydney Raw (1950–1952)
Rear-Admiral George Simpson (1952–1954)
Rear-Admiral George Fawkes (1954–1955)
Rear-Admiral Wilfrid Woods (1955–1957)
Rear-Admiral Bertram Taylor (1957–1959)
Rear-Admiral Arthur Hezlet (1959–1961)
Rear-Admiral Hugh Mackenzie (1961–1963)
Rear-Admiral Horace Law (1963–1965)
Rear-Admiral Ian McGeoch (1965–1967)
Vice-Admiral Sir Michael Pollock (1967–1969)
Vice-Admiral Sir John Roxburgh (1969–1972)
Vice-Admiral Anthony Troup (1972–1974)
Vice-Admiral Sir Iwan Raikes (1974–1976)
Vice-Admiral John Fieldhouse (1976–1978)
Vice-Admiral Robert Squires (1978–1981)
Vice-Admiral Sir Peter Herbert (1981–1983)
Vice-Admiral Sir John Woodward (1983–1984)
Rear-Admiral Richard Heaslip (1984–1987)
Rear-Admiral Frank Grenier (1987–1989)
Vice-Admiral Sir John Coward (1989–1991)
Vice-Admiral Toby Frere (1991–1994)
Rear-Admiral Roger Lane-Nott (1994–1996)
Admiral James Perowne (1996–1998)
Rear-Admiral Robert Stevens (1998–2001)
Rear-Admiral Niall Kilgour (2001–February 2002)^[13]

Rear-Admiral Submarines

Rear-Admiral Niall Kilgour (February 2002 – 2004^[13]), post became the 'tribal chief' of Royal Navy submarines
Rear-Admiral Ian Corder (2011-2013)
Rear-Admiral Matt Parr (2013-2015)
Rear-Admiral Robert Tarrant (2015)
Rear Admiral John Weale (2015-2020)

Commodore Submarine Service

Commodore James Perks CBE (2020–2022): as of December 2020, Senior Naval Officer Scotland and Northern Ireland, Deputy Director Submarines, and Commodore Submarine Service.^[12]
Commodore Paul Dunn OBE (2022–present)^[14]

References

^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f Harley & Lovell 2015.
^ "Submarine School". Retrieved 6 September 2015.
^ "Royal, Dominion & Allied Navies in World War II: Beginning and End, 1939 and 1945". Naval-history.net. 2010.
^ ^a ^b Roskill, Stephen W. (1954). "Chapter 4: Allied and Enemy War Plans and Dispositions". History of the Second World War: The War at Sea 1939-1945: The Defensive. London: HMSO. pp. 47–49.
^ "Submarine History: Submarine Service: Operations and Support". Royal Navy. 2008. Archived from the original on 13 September 2008.
^ Chalmers (1954), Chapter X.
^ Conley, p. 136
^ ^a ^b ^c "Senior Royal Navy Appointments" (PDF). Retrieved 6 September 2015.
^ "Rear Admiral John Weale" (PDF). Retrieved 21 January 2016.
^ ^a ^b Submariners Association (2016). "FORMATION OF THE SUBMARINE FLOTILLA (SUBFLOT) (Serial Galaxy 30-2015 Dated 15th December 2015)" (PDF). PERISCOPE VIEW The Newsletter of the Barrow-in Furness Branch of the Submariners Association.
^ ^a ^b See it here
^ ^a ^b "Response to Freedom of Information Request". Ministry of Defence. 16 December 2020. Retrieved 15 April 2022.
^ ^a ^b "Rear Admiral Niall Kilgour (Chairman of Trustees) – Royal Navy Club of 1765 and 1785 (united 1889)". Retrieved 2022-04-15.
^ "Celebrated head of the Royal Navy's Submarine Service retires". Royal Navy. 26 July 2022. Retrieved 26 July 2022.

Harley, Simon; Lovell, Tony (3 November 2015). "Inspecting Captain of Submarines - The Dreadnought Project". www.dreadnoughtproject.org. Harley and Lovell. Retrieved 15 March 2018.
"U.K. to Relocate Two Attack Boats to Scotland by 2020". USNI News. 1 December 2014. Retrieved 16 April 2022.

Sources

Conley, Dan (2014). Cold War Command: The Dramatic Story of a Nuclear Submariner. Seaforth Publishing. ISBN 9781848327696.
Chalmers, William (1954). Max Horton and the Western Approaches: A biography of Admiral Sir Max Kennedy Horton. Hodder & Stoughton.

His Majesty's Naval Service

Leadership

Components

Royal Navy	Surface fleet Fleet Air Arm Submarine Service Royal Navy Medical Service Nursing Service (QARNNS) Chaplaincy Service Navy Police Naval Careers Service
Royal Marines	3 Commando Brigade Royal Marines Band Service Royal Marines Reserve Royal Marines Police
Royal Naval Reserve	HMS Calliope HMS Cambria HMS Ceres HMS Dalriada HMS Eaglet HMS Ferret HMS Flying Fox HMS Forward HMS Hibernia HMS King Alfred HMS President HMS Scotia HMS Sherwood HMS Vivid HMS Wildfire
Special Forces	Special Boat Service

History
and
future

Admiralty in the 16th century
Admiralty in the 17th century
Admiralty in the 18th century
Customs and traditions
Historic forces and commands
Future of the Royal Navy
History of the Royal Navy (before 1707) (after 1707)
History of the Royal Marines
National Maritime Museum
National Museum of the Royal Navy
Naval Historical Branch

Operating
forces

Fleet Commander
Commander United Kingdom Strike Force
Commander Operations
Surface Flotilla
Submarine Flotilla
3 Commando Brigade

Fleet

Ships

Administration

Defence Council
Admiralty Board
Navy Board
Navy Command

Senior
officers

Assistant Chief of the Naval Staff (Aviation, Amphibious Capability & Carriers)
Assistant Chief of the Naval Staff (Capability)
Director People & Training
Assistant Chief of the Naval Staff (Policy)
Director Naval Support
Commander Fleet Operational Sea Training
Chaplain of the Fleet
Director General Ships
Commandant General Royal Marines
Commander Operations
Commander United Kingdom Strike Force
Commander Littoral Strike Group
Commander United Kingdom Carrier Strike Group
Commodore, Naval Staff
Commodore RFA and Deputy Director Royal Navy Afloat Support
Commander Maritime Reserves
Naval Secretary
Rear-Admiral, Fleet Air Arm
Commodore Submarine Flotilla
Commodore Surface Flotilla
Serving senior officers
Serving senior Royal Marines officers

Personnel
and
training

Equipment

Former
leadership

category

v t e Navy Department (Ministry of Defence)
political head ministers	Office of the Minister of Defence for the Royal Navy (1964-1967) Office of the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Defence for the Royal Navy (1967-1981) Deputy Under-Secretary of State (Navy) (1967-1981) Office of the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for the Armed Forces (1981-1990) Office of the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Defence (1991-1997)
governance	Defence Council Defence Board Admiralty Board Navy Board
military head	First Sea Lord and Chief of Naval Staff
office of the first sea lord	Office of the Vice-Chief of the Naval Staff Office of the Deputy-Chief of the Naval Staff Office of the Naval Secretary-flag officer appointments - Naval Assistant to Naval Secretary-captains appointments Director of Naval Officer Appointments Director of Naval Officer Appointments (Engineer Officers) Director of Naval Officer Appointments (Seaman Officers) Director of Naval Officer Appointments (Supply and Secretariat and WRNS Officers) Director of Naval Security (1988-) Naval Assistant to the First Sea Lord Secretary to the First Sea Lord
under Vice & Deputy Chief of Naval Staff	Offices of the Assistant Chiefs of the Naval Staff Commandant General Royal Marines Chief of Staff Colonel General Staff (Assistant Chief of Staff) Military Secretary (Royal Marines) Assistant Adjutant-General (Royal Marines) Assistant Quartermaster- General (Royal Marines) Director Royal Marines Reserves Directorate of Naval Security Director of Naval Security Hydrographer of the Navy Assistant Hydrographer Officers appointments Director of Naval Oceanography and Meteorology Director of Hydrographic Plans and Surveys Director of Hydrographic Charting and Sciences Director of Hydrographic Administration and Supply
Air, Operations, Plans, Policy requirements, warfare	Assistant Chief of the Naval Staff (Policy) Assistant of Chief Defence Staff (Pol) Naval Staff Assistant Chief of the Naval Staff Assistant Chief of the Naval Staff (Operations) Assistant Chief of the Naval Staff (Operations and Air) Assistant Chief of Defence Staff (Ops) Naval Staff Assistant Chief of the Naval Staff (Operational Requirements) Assistant Chief of the Naval Staff (Warfare)
naval staff directorates offices & branches	Directorate of Communications & Information Systems (Navy) Directorate of Defence Plans (Navy) Directorate of Defence Policy(Naval) Directorate of Fleet Management Services Directorate of Naval Air Warfare Operation Directorate of Naval Management and Organisation Directorate of Operational Analysis (RN) Directorate of Naval Operations and Trade Directorate of Naval Operational Requirements Directorate of Naval Plans Directorate of Naval Tactical and Weapons Policy Directorate of Naval Security Directorate of Naval Signals Directorate of Naval Staff Duties Directorate of Navigation and Tactical Control (Naval) Directorate of Surface Warfare (Naval) Directorate of Under-Sea Warfare (Naval) Hydrographic Department Naval Historical Branch Naval Historical Library Naval Staff Directorate Plans and Resources Division
naval personnel	Office of the Second Sea Lord and Chief of Naval Personnel
naval personnel department	Office of the Chief Naval Supply and Secretariat Officer Office of the Chaplain of the Fleet-became Royal Navy Chaplaincy Service Principal Chaplain Church of Scotland & Free Churches (Naval) Principal Roman Catholic Chaplain (Naval) Directorate General Training Directorate-General Naval Manpower and Training Director of Naval Manpower Planning Director of Naval Manpower Requirements Director of Naval Manning and Training (Seaman) Director of Naval Manning and Training (Engineering) Director of Naval Manning and Training (Supply and Secretariat) Director of Naval Training Support Naval Manpower Statistics Branch Director of Naval Foreign and Commonwealth Training Director of Naval Education Service Joint Warfare Establishment Directorate-General Naval Personal Services Directorate of Naval Officer Appointments Directorate of Naval Physical Training and Sports Head of Naval Social Service Directorate of Naval Service Conditions Director of Naval Service Conditions Directorate of Fleet Supply Duties (1964-1973) General Manager Royal Navy Film Corporation Job Evaluation Judge Naval Recruitment Training Agency Office of the Admiral Commanding, Reserves Office of the Medical Director-General of the Navy Office of the Medical Director-General (Naval) Deputy Director-General (Naval) Director Naval Dental Services Director of Medical Personnel and Logistics Director of Naval Recruiting Women's Royal Naval Service Headquarters became- Office of the Matron-in-Chief Queen Alexandra's Royal Naval Nursing Service
controller	Controller of the Navy
controllers department navy controllerate	Assistant Controller of the Navy Office of the Chief Executive Polaris Deputy Controller Polaris Department of the Director of Naval Construction Weapons Department (Naval) Director-General Weapons (Naval) Director Weapons Coordination and Acceptance (Naval) Co-Ordination Directorate Compass Directorate Director Naval Ordnance Services Director Naval Weapons Contracts B Director Underwater Weapons Projects (Naval) Director Weapons Surface Projects (Naval) Director Surface Electronic Projects (Naval) Department of the Director-General Aircraft (Naval) Naval Ordnance Inspection Directorate Production Directorate Director Weapons Production (Naval) Surface Weapons Research and Development Directorate Under Water Weapons Research and Development Directorate Weapons Equipment Surface Directorate Ship Department Deputy Director-General Ships- Director of Contracts (Ships) Director Engineering (Ships) Director of Electrical Engineering Director of Naval Construction Director of Naval Equipment Director of Project Team Submarines/Polaris Director of Resources and Programmes (Ships) Director Warship Design Directorate of Naval Construction Marine Engineering Directorate Naval Equipment Division Naval Equipment Directorate Naval Electrical Engineering Directorate Naval Ship Production Directorate Principal Director of Navy Contracts
naval supplies and transport fleet support hq naval support command	Office of the Chief of Naval Supplies and Transport Office of the Chief of Fleet Support
under naval supplies and transport fleet support hq naval support command	Assistant Chief of Fleet Support Director of Naval Administrative Planning Director of Fleet Supply Duties Director of Fleet Maintenance Director of Marine Services Head of Aircraft Department (Naval) HQ Director of Quartering (Navy) Civil Catering Department Contract and Purchase Department (Naval) Department of Fuel Movements and Transport (Naval) Department of Dockyards and Fleet Maintenance Dockyard Division Fleet Maintenance Division Marine Services Division Office of the Chief Executive Royal Dockyards- Director of Dockyard Manpower and Productivity Director of Dockyard Production and Support Director of Finance and Administration Directorate-General of Supplies and Transport Director of Supplies and Transport (Management and Administration) Director of Supplies and Transport (General and Victualling) Victualling Division Director of Supplies and Transport (Fuel and Movements) Director of Supplies and Transport (Armament and Specialist) Director of Supplies and Transport (Finance) Naval Stores Department Royal Naval Supply and Transport Service Victualling Department (1832-1971)
chief scientists department	Office of the Chief Scientist (Royal Navy) also Deputy Controller Research and Development Establishments, and Research A Director Research Ships Director Research Underwater
under chief scientists department	Royal Naval Scientific Service Headquarters Deputy Chief Scientist (Navy) Directorate Naval Operational Studies Director of Naval Operational Studies Office of the Senior Psychologist (Naval) Admiralty Compass Observatory Department of Naval Physical Research Department of Research and Development Services (Naval) Department of Material Research (Naval) Director-General Establishments, Resources and Programmes A Admiralty Engineering Laboratory Admiralty Experiment Works Admiralty Marine Engineering Establishment Admiralty Oil Laboratory Admiralty Research Laboratory Admiralty Research Establishment Admiralty Surface Weapons Establishment Admiralty Underwater Weapons Establishment Naval Construction Research Establishment Royal Naval Physiological Laboratory Royal Radar Establishment Signals Research and Development Establishment Director-General Research Electronics Services Electronics Research Laboratory
naval home command	Naval Home Command
Shore units under Naval Home Command	Admiral-Superintendent, Devonport Admiral-superintendent, Portsmouth Admiral Commanding, Reserves Commodore, Clyde Submarine Base Chief Executive Officer Marine Services Flag Officer Commanding, Royal Yachts Flag Officer, Medway Flag Officer, Plymouth Port Admiral, Devonport Flag Officer, Portsmouth and Admiral-superintendent, Portsmouth Flag Officer Spithead and Port Admiral Portsmouth Flag Officer, Training and Recruitment Senior Naval Officer, Northern Ireland
Fleets	Home Fleet Far East Fleet Mediterranean Fleet Western Fleet Commander-in-Chief Fleet
under c-in-c, fleet	Chief of Staff Fleet Chief of Staff, (Warfare) Fleet Chief of Staff (Capability) Fleet Chief of Staff (Personnel) Fleet Assistant Chief of Staff, Operations Assistant Chief of Staff, Plans Assistant Chief of Staff, Warfare Command Secretary, Fleet Commandant General Royal Marines Commander British Forces Gibraltar Commander Operations Commander UK Amphibious Forces Commander United Kingdom Maritime Forces Flag Officer, Carriers and Amphibious Ships Flag Officer First Flotilla Flag Officer, Second Flotilla Flag Officer, Third Flotilla Flag Officer, Surface Flotilla Flag Officer Gibraltar and Gibraltar Naval Base Commander Flag Officer Scotland, Northern England, Northern Ireland Flag Officer Scotland and Northern Ireland Flag Officer Plymouth Flag Officer Sea Training Flag Officer Submarines Flag Officer Naval Air Command Flag Officer, Flying Training Flag Officer, Naval Flying Training
under c-in-c home fleet, far east fleet mediterranean fleet, western fleet	Flag Officer Second-in-Command Far East Fleet Chief of Staff, Far East Fleet Commodore, Amphibious Forces, Far East Fleet Commodore-in-Charge, Hong Kong Mediterranean Fleet Chief of Staff Mediterranean Fleet Flag Officer, Gibraltar Commodore (D) Commanding, Mediterranean Fleet Destroyers Rear-Admiral (D) Commanding, Mediterranean Fleet Destroyers Vice-Admiral (D) Commanding, Mediterranean Fleet Destroyers Western Fleet Chief of Staff, Western Fleet
civil administration navy department	Office of the Second Permanent Under-Secretary of State (Royal Navy) Office of the Second Permanent Under-Secretary of State (Administration)
under civil administration	Department of the Permanent Under-Secretary of State (Royal Navy) Department of the Permanent Under-Secretary of State (Administration) Greenwich Hospital Department
Naval Legal	Office of the Counsel to the Navy Department, Ministry of Defence Office of the Judge Advocate of the Fleet Office of the Chief Naval Judge Advocate